Art Issues Paper



Joni Hough
February 19, 2010
ARTE 5122

Art Issue Paper

In art, traditional is non-Western and modern is Western. It is as simple as that! Or is it? Like most things, it is not that simple. Western and non-Western cultures have greatly influenced each other. Also, there are serious implications for art education when non-Western art is assumed to be traditional and Western art is assumed to be modern.

To begin this discussion, the terms “Western,” “non-Western,” “traditional,” and “modern” must be defined. Metcalfe (2010) points out that defining “Western” can be complicated, with the “exact scope of the Western World is somewhat subjective in nature, depending on whether cultural, economic or political criteria are used.” Although usually the countries of Western Europe, the United States, Canada, Australia and New Zealand are included even though they are not all part of the Western Hemisphere (Metcalfe 2010). In Art History’s History, Minor (2001) states, “The term Western identifies enormous numbers of people of diverse concerns, ideologies, economic backgrounds, historical origins, classes and ethnicities” (p. 206). But Minor later points out that culturally “Western” refers to “European, Anglo, and American white men and women, educated beyond the secondary level by the study of great books, great works of art, great scientific theories, great philosophical systems, great forms of government, great religions, and great social institutions” (p. 206-207). By this definition, many people who are geographically Western are not culturally Western.

Defining “non-Western” is just as complicated. The term “non-Western” is biased by its very nature, because it refers to a large part of the world by what it is not, rather than what is. Synonyms used for non-Western, including, “preindustrial societies” (Congdon 1989, p. 180), “the Third World” (Minor 2001, p. 207), “the East” (Minor 2001, p. 207) and “traditional societies” (Strother 1995), are no less problematic. These terms are largely prejudicial and/or inaccurate in their descriptions. The regions generally associated with the non-West include Asia, Africa, India, Latin America, and the Middle East (Osborn 2009). Not only are these vastly different regions with their own cultures, but as with the countries in the West, they are not all even in the Eastern Hemisphere. These terms are insufficient, and educators need to use more precise language when referring to any part of the world.

Tradition, as defined by Delahunt (n.d.), “is the passing along of a culture from generation to generation, especially orally.” This method of socialization is not exclusive to either the West or the non-West. Some of the synonyms used to describe traditional art include primitive art, folk art, ethnic art, and indigenous art (Delahunt n.d.). These terms carry with them a connotation that traditional art is lesser than nontraditional art. According to Blocker (2001), traditional art is that which is produced by people who are not European or American. By this definition, non-Western art (and some Western art) is automatically traditional, simply by means of who made the art. This definition does not take into account the type of art, its purpose, or its context.

Gablik (1984) describes modernism as, “the term that has been used to describe the art and culture of the past hundred years” (p. 11). In Gablik’s definition there is no distinction made as to whether the art or culture of the past hundred years is Western or non-Western. This lack of distinction could be because Gablik believes that modernism is universal or it could be ethnocentrism, were Gablik is simply omitting then art and culture of the non-West. Blocker (2001) on the other hand, refers to modernism as the period, “in Europe roughly from the end of the seventeenth century through the early decades of the twentieth century” (p. 8). By this account, modernism is exclusively a Western phenomenon. According to Gablik (1984), Blocker (2001), and Minor (2001), the key idea of modernism is art for art’s sake. Blocker (2001) further states that the “ideas of ‘aesthetic enjoyment’ and ‘fine art’ and ‘artist’ were socially constructed and culturally inculcated in what we call the ‘modern’ period” (p. 8).



The idea that traditional art is non-Western and modern art is Western is not at all simple or accurate. This statement ignores the many artists in the West that do not prescribe to modernist notion of “art for art’s sake.” For example, African American artists, such as Jacob Lawrence and Faith Ringgold, whose works have highlighted social issues. Lawrence created a series of work that focused on the occupations available to African Americans in 1940’s Harlem. Ringgold’s triptych, Street Story Quilt, also set in Harlem, is a story of survival and redemption.

There are also examples of non-Western artists who have created modern art. For example, Indian artist, Natvar Bhavsar, whose formalist work deals with the color, yellow. Chilean artist, Matta’s (Roberto Matta Echaurren) Being With (Être Avec), is a massive surrealistic painting, which is a subgenre of modernism. Another non-Western modern artist is Israeli sculpture, Yaacov Agam. His 1966 piece, Relief Rhythm, is abstract geometric forms created from painted wood.

The statement, traditional art is non-Western and modern art is Western, also does not take into account the hybridization of the West and the non-West that has come from globalization. Artist Yinka Shonibare MBE, for instance, was born in England to Nigerian parents.   He grew up traveling between Lagos, Nigeria and London, England and his work deals with cultural identity (Art: 21 n.d.). African American artist, Elizabeth Catlett is another multicultural artist. Catlett began her career in the United States, but in 1946 she moved to Mexico, where she continues to live. She joined the Taller de Gráfica Popular, a printmaking workshop in Mexico City. Her work combines the printmaking she studied in Mexico with archetypal African American women, such as in her lithograph, Mother and Child (Metropolitan Museum of Art n.d.). Biracial artist, John Feodorov is of Navajo and European American decent. He grew up in the Suburbs of Los Angeles and on a Navajo reservation. Feodorov’s work comically confronts Native American stereotypes, as in his mixed-media sculpture, Animal Spirit Channeling Device for the Contemporary Shaman (Art: 21 n.d.).

Modern art can not exist without the influence of traditional arts. As modern artists try to produce something more unique and unusual, they find that, “to be modern now is to be traditional.”  Additionally, “Artists are finding that the only way to make something new is to borrow from the past.” (Gablik 1984, p. 117). This is true with many fiber artists, who utilize art techniques and media that often derives from the traditions of women’s domestic arts or folk art. For instance, Miriam Schapiro’s The Poet #2, uses fabric and quilt blocks (University Art Museum, University at Albany SUNY n.d.).

Pablo Picasso was influenced by the traditional Africa masks and Paul Gauguin drew inspiration from traditional Tahitian sculpture (Museum of Modern Art n.d.). This can be seen in Picasso’s Les Demoiselles d'Avignon and in Gauguin’s Te Atua (The Gods) from Noa Noa (Fragrance.)

Traditional influences can also be seen in many forms of architecture. For example, Houseplans.com (n.d.) features house plan categories for Tudor, Victorian, Colonial, and Plantation styles. Additionally, many of the United States’ federal buildings, such as the White House and the Supreme Court building, are designed after Greek and Roman architectural styles.


Vestiges of the past can be seen modern art. According to Minor (2001) “The ‘West’ as an idea results from a pattern of history that originates in Greece and Rome, moves through the Christian Middle Ages, Renaissance, Enlightenment, and into the European-Anglo culture and economy of the present day” (p. 208). For example, images of the Christian crucifixion have been portrayed throughout art history. A Byzantine book cover from Constantinople, from over a thousand years ago, has a crucifixion carved in it. There is also a 17th century brass crucifixion made by the Kongo peoples from the Democratic Republic of Congo. Romare Bearden’s Golgotha, from 1945, portrays a crucifixion using watercolor, India ink, and pencil on paper (Metropolitan Museum of Art n,d.). In 1987, Andres Serrano created controversy with his crucifixion photograph, Piss Christ (Artnet.com n.d.).

.









There are serious implications for teachers who believe that Western art is modern and non-Western art is traditional. Minor (2001) states, “In the view of multiculturalism, accepting the Western or white consciousness as representing a natural or real view of the world is distorting and potentially racist” (p. 208). Chalmers (1992) goes further by pointing out that “art curricula, and much art educational thinking, are, or have been, ethnocentric,” which “is an implicit part of racism,” and occurs when “a person unreflectively takes his own culture's values as objective reality and automatically uses them as the context within which he judges less familiar objects and events...it does not occur to such a person that there is more than one point of view” (p. 134). This attitude is counterintuitive to teaching students to be the creative, critical thinkers. An ethnocentric curriculum does not address the needs of the diverse students of the United States.

To counteract the Western centric education students have received, Chalmers (1992) states that art teachers should be, “knowledgeable about and sensitive to students' differing cultural backgrounds, values, and traditions,” “demonstrate respect for cultures and backgrounds different from their own and acknowledge that all groups can produce and define cultural artifacts that are ‘excellent’ and that in all cultures ‘art’ exists for rather similar reasons,” “provide a classroom atmosphere in which students' cultures are recognized, shared, and respected,” “develop culturally appropriate curricula materials to supplement those whose treatment of different cultural groups is limited or biased,” and “give students an opportunity to explore what they do not know or understand about the arts of other cultures” (p. 142).


References
Art: 21. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.pbs.org/art21.
Artnet.com. (n.d.). Retrieved from www.artnet.com/artwork/424288434/piss-christ.html.
Blocker, G. (2001). Non-Western aesthetics as a colonial invention. Journal of Aesthetic
Education 35(4) 3-13.
Brooklyn Museum of Art. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.brooklynmuseum.org.
Chalmers, F. G. (1992). The origins of racism in the public school art curriculum. Studies in Art
Education 33(3) 134-143.
Congdon, K. G. (1989). Multi-cultural approaches to art criticism. Studies in Art Education 30(3)
176-184.
Delahunt, M. (n.d.) Artlex art dictionary. Retrieved from http://www.artlex.com/.
Gablik, S. (1984). Has modernism failed? New York, NY: Thames and Hudson Inc.
Houseplans.com. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.houseplans.com.
Metcalfe, L. (2010). Nationmaster.com. Retrieved from
http://www.statemaster.com/encyclopedia/Western-world.
Metropolitan Museum of Art. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.metmuseum.org.
Minor, V. H. (2001). Art history’s history. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Museum of Modern Art. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.moma.org.
Osborn, T. (2009). Teacher Oz's kingdom of history. Retrieved from
http://www.teacheroz.com/Non_Western.htm.
Strother, Z. S. (1995). Invention and reinvention in the traditional arts. African Arts 2(2) 24-
33+90.
Supremecourtus.gov. (n.d.). Retrieved from www.supremecourtus.gov.
University Art Museum, University at Albany SUNY. (n.d.). Retrieved from
http://www.albany.edu/museum/.
Whitehouse.gov. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.whitehouse.gov.

Multicultural Artworlds: Chapter 2 Summary/Response

Joni Hough
February 9, 2010
ARTE 5122

Multicultural Artworlds: Chapter 2 Summary/Response

In chapter two of Multicultural Artworlds, Mary Erickson defines artworlds and discusses their importance. She begins by pointing out that cultures are sustained by people who get their identity from shared experiences. Cultures have traditionally been based on ethnicity, political boundaries, language, and religion; however, they can also be based on shared interests, such as interest in sports, food, fashion, cars, music, business, politics, and the arts. Teachers have a responsibility to teach students about the multicultural nature of North America.

Erickson defines artworlds as subcultures focused on art that have developed within the larger cultures of various ethnic groups. The artwork created within these artworlds can carry meaning for the larger culture and can be a resource for understanding that culture. These artworlds can also be a central concept around which a multicultural art curriculum is structured.

There are many distinct, yet interrelated artworlds in North America, including the mainstream museum artworld, folk artworlds, commercial artworlds, ceremonial artworlds, and artworlds of many ethnic groups. Within any ethnic group, there are diverse, evolving, overlapping artworlds.

To understand a culture one must understand that culture’s ideas and activities. Studying important people and places within a culture provides concrete examples to help explain that culture’s ideas and activities to students.

Artworlds serve several different functions. For example, different artworlds have different definitions of what constitutes art. Teaching students about diverse artworlds, allows them to more broadly define art for themselves. Artworlds also enable art making, by offering artists support and education. By learning about many artworlds, students have the opportunity to discover the knowledge that is maintained and passed on by those artworlds. Artworlds provide meaning for artworks. If students are not taught about the contextual artworld in which an artwork is made, they can not fully appreciate that artwork. Art not only reflects the artworld in which it is made, it also affects society. By understanding a variety of artworlds, student can recognize the many ways art functions in different cultures. Finally, artworlds offer support to those who wish to make art and to those who wish to understand art. Students who have access to myriad artworlds have access support systems they can use for lifelong learning.

My Response
This chapter has given me a new perspective on how to address my art issue assignment. The issue of “Western art is modern and non-Western art is traditional” is too narrow a view of art. This idea ignores a vast majority of artworlds from both Western and non-Western cultures. There are so many more artworlds than just modern or traditional. I knew I disagreed with that statement, however before reading this chapter, I could not satisfactorily explain to myself why I disagreed with it.

Also, I agree with this chapter that students need to learn about artworlds and understand the context of artworks. However, I think that having student compare and contrast different artworlds, without creating hierarchical categories, would give students a more comprehensive understanding of art.

Notes on: Delacruz, E. (2003). Racism American style and resistance to change: Art education’s role in the Indian mascot issue. Art Education, 56 (3), 13-20

“I have considered how Native Americans' pleas to eliminate this practice (of using Indian mascots) have been met with such strong resistance by individuals who seem thoughtful, well educated, and not particularly racist. I wondered why, in denial of compelling arguments against, this use of Indian mascots persists. I concluded that this form of unintended racism is just too much fun to give up, too easy to ignore, too ‘normal’ to abandon. Americans just love their Indians to death.”

“Selected cases involving uses of Indian mascots by non-Native American educational institutions and sports teams provide a context for considering the value systems of those who continue to employ this practice. Impediments to change reframe the problem in a larger context, a context that considers centuries of White privilege and power in this country.”

Selected Cases
“Issues of voice, tradition, impact, and resistance to change permeate these and other cases involving the use of Indian mascots by non-Native Americans.”

Chief Osceola at Florida State University
“…FSU representatives assert that Chief Osceola has the approval of Native Americans.”

“Ashcoff (2000) notes lack of agreement with such a claim, ‘They can always find a hang-around-the-fort Indian to say it's okay,’ says Vemon Bellecourt, president of the National Coalition Against Racism in Sports and Media and a national AIM [American Indian Movement] board member. ‘This issue is larger than the Seminole nation. The mascots are used to represent all Indians.’ (p. 1F)”

Ashcoff points out particularly perplexing problems facing opponents of popular uses of Indian mascots, slurs, and caricatures-harassment and public indifference…”

The Issaquah Indian: Issaquah Seattle
“At the end of May of 2002, the Issaquah School Board moved forward to adopt a new policy that mandates mascots and logos be free from stereotyping, derogatory or offensive connotations, and not likely to divide the community in significant controversy. Some students planned a school-wide walkout and petition drive in protest to Board actions.”

The Washington Redskins
“After 7 years of litigation, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit recently upheld a 1999 ruling of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Board that ordered the cancellation of federal registration of Washington Redskins trademarks.”

“The Patent and Trademark Board found the Redskins trademark to be disparaging to Native Americans. Federal trademark law specifies that names cannot be protected if they are ‘disparaging, scandalous, contemptuous or disreputable’ (Moreno, 1998).”

“John Paul Reiner, attorney for Pro-Football Inc., which owns the Washington Redskins, originally argued that the term "Redskins" is not a slur and compared it to the use of the word "colored" in the name of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (Moreno, 1998).”

“Raymond Apodaca, a former governor of a Texas tribe, compared the word ‘Redskins’ to ‘the 'N word' for African Americans and all kinds of pejoratives that exist for Jews, for Hispanics, for women none of which would ever be accepted or tolerated in relation to sports or anything else.’”

“…the term "Redskins" was originally used by White settlers as a way to count the number of Indian scalps collected by trappers and other Indian exterminators. Native Americans dealing with the Indian mascot issue refer to ‘Redskins’ as the ‘R-Word’ (cited in Moreno, 1998).”

Chief Illiniwek
“Chief Illiniwek, a 75-year-old ‘tradition’ at the Urbana-Champaign campus, and a registered trademark of the university, has been the topic of controversy for 14 years now. One problem is that Chief Illiniwek is dressed as a Lakota Sioux, not one of the original Illini Nations. But more to the issue is that the Chief does not represent any Indian, past or present, and what he does represent is racism and miseducation, sanctioned in a major research institution.”

“Central to the arguments and counter arguments are contested definitions of what constitutes honor, tradition, and racism. Arguments in favor of the Chief include references to his value as a ‘tradition,’ claims that fans ‘honor’ Native culture, emotional attachment to his role as a nostalgic link for alumni, charges of political correctness by a vocal minority, and fear of lost revenues if the Chief is retired.”

“Opponents argue that the Chief is a White-concocted, mythologized caricature of Indians (the noble savage), that misrepresents Native American culture, mocks sacred Native American beliefs and rituals, miseducates the public, and hurts the self-image of Native American children.”

Why Do These Practices Persist?
“For the better part of the 20th century, Wild West shows, Hollywood, the Boy Scouts, advertising industries, public educational institutions, and businesses across the country have banked on their own version of Chiefs, Braves, Spirit Guides, and Squaws.”

“Authenticity and history are forsaken in favor of commercial and entertainment interests. But in reality, most Anglo-Americans actually know little if anything about the beliefs, values, cosmology, or cultural practices of any Native Americans, past or present.”

“Indian Mascots are still used in over 1500 public schools throughout the United States.”

“Teachers and students, parents and children in and near these communities experience these and other stereotyped images in television broadcasts, print media, on billboards, tee shirts, baseball caps, boxer shorts, silk panties, and toilet paper.”

“Matthew Richter explains that Indian mascots first came into use by White schools in the 1920s, in conjunction with practices emanating from the Indian Boarding Schools. By Richter's account, Native American children were forcibly removed from their homes and incarcerated in institutions that were in reality work camps run by Christian churches. These children were forced to work to produce salable goods for hours each day and attended school only 4 hours or less each day, doing what Richer characterizes as ‘pseudo academic exercises to create a feel good and economic enterprise for White America.’”

“Vernellia Randall, professor of law, writing for the Transnational Racial Justice Initiative, explains that the continued contemporary practices associated with the uses of Indian mascots, imagery, and performance are rooted in what Randall calls the persistence of white privilege- ‘a system that accrues to whites or European Americans greater wealth, resources, more access and higher quality access to justice, services, capital-virtually every form of benefits to be reaped from U.S. society-than other racial groups’ (Randall, 2001, para. 2)”

 “Randall argues that the U.S. Government must recognize its culpability in related issues of racism and inequity and immediately institute comprehensive remedies and reparations that address the deep and abiding racism, repression, and discrimination.”

Why Should Art Educators Care About Indian Mascots?
“Fictional Indian mascots, who live in an imaginary past and mythological present, teach non-Natives very little about Native people and culture. Instead, Indian mascots promote the premise that everything ‘real or valuable’ about Natives belonged to a long lost era, before the race was overtaken by manifest destiny. Real Natives face real problems that are neither romantic nor extinct... It is an undeniable and documented fact that Native-based mascots teach and perpetuate stereotypes which directly undermine the self-determination, dignity and well-being of Native people, as well as create a hostile school, work, economic and social environment for over two million Native men, women and children... Native youth suffer the most, having the highest teen suicide and drop-out rates of any racial or cultural group. Prejudice derived directly from stereotypes has been cited as the primary factor for all of the above. (Beaudet, cited in Garippo, 2001, Section V. Summary Position of the Illinois Native American Bar Association)”

“It's easy to ignore this issue of miseducation and social inequity. These are missed opportunities for dialogue with students about real problems associated with the power of images and for a beginning of the dismantling of the value system that allows one group of individuals to depict another with such intellectual dishonesty and hostility.”

“Art teachers and teacher educators need to become more informed about the issues surrounding Indian mascots and to make our collective position clear on the use of race-based mascots and imagery in educational institutions and sports teams. Our silence on this issue, even if not intentional, is in effect a form of tacit racism and cultural violence…”

“A good beginning point for addressing this and other issues based curricular goals would involve the study of the artwork of contemporary Native American artists who have addressed the issue of misrepresentation of cultures in their work.' Framed within a thoughtfully constructed multicultural art program, the study of Native American art, history, cultural values, and contemporary issues would enrich our understandings about the power of art, deepen our understanding of our history with First Nations peoples, and provide more productive frames of reference as we co-construct our collective futures.”

“Beyond aesthetic appreciation and cultural consumption of Native American art, history, and cultural practices, we are compelled to seek social, political, and economic justice and equity on behalf of those we claim to appreciate.”

Footnote
“The work of contemporary Native American artists including, but certainly not limited to Ron Anderson, Judy Baca, Karita Coffey, Jessie Cooday, Rick Glazer Danay, Rupert Garcia, Carmen Lomez Garza, Ester Hernandez, Edgar Heap-of-Birds, Allan Houser, Edna Davis Jackson, George Longfish, George Littlechild, Yolanda Lopez, James Luna, Dan Naminga, Jaune Quick-to-See-Smith, Roxanne Swentzell, Charlene Teters, Hulleah Tsinhahjinnie, Kay Walkingstick, and Randy Lee White are reasonably accessible on-line or in books and journals.”

Notes on Ulbright, J. (2003). Learning about political art in the classroom and community. Art Education, 56 (3), 6-12.

“Although art teachers often teach about the formal qualities of art, they should be more concerned with its functions, including those that are political. Such a concern would show the power of art and make it more relevant to students.”

Definitions
“Historically, one thinks of prime political art examples to include Delacroix's Liberty Leading the People, Goya's The Third Day of May, Picasso's Guernica, and Rivera's murals (Von Blum, 1976). Students and teachers can find additional examples of political art by Courbet, Daumier, Beckman, Kollwitz, and Grosz in thematic art history texts such as those by Lewis and Lewis (1994) and Lazzari and Schlesier (2002).”

“Contemporary artists often express what some would call political points of view through their art, and the reader can see examples of this in the work of Lynne Hull (pollution), Fred Wilson (racism), and Jaune Quick-to-See Smith (unjust treatment of Native peoples).”

“While some teachers may not want to bother with the political analysis of art, Feldman (1978) stated that art is a catalyst that makes things happen, and he urged teachers to teach about the important ideas that artists try to communicate.”

Controversy
“Especially in conservative communities, teachers should be concerned with the possible ramifications of political art discussions, but this should not hinder their attempts to include them in a manner appropriate to students' understandings.”

“Smith (1996) implied that if teachers devoted more time to art's social concerns, then art instruction might be seen as useful and have a more secure place in the school curriculum.”

“In the last 50 years, Modem artists tried to assert their independence from powerful people and ordinary citizens, but lately Postmodern artists made art as if the world mattered (Gablik 1991, 1995).”

Related Literature
“Coles (1986) found that children have a developing awareness of many political issues, and teachers could provide opportunities for students to see the artistic and expressive applications of their knowledge.”

“…Kincheloe, Slattery, and Steinberg (2000)…emphasize contextualizing education by making meaningful connections between teaching and communities. Such a community concern is important to many contemporary and community-based artists.”

“Students should consider the significance of all visual imagery by looking at its ideology, source, and sponsorship (Duncum, 2002).”

“At a time when most teachers try to take into consideration the genetic and cultural differences of their students, it is important that they learn about the political art of multicultural artists whose work may call attention to special circumstances.”

“Viewers can find relevant examples in the work of Barbara Kruger, Yolanda Lopez, Robert Colescott, Michael Ray Charles, and Luis Jimenez.”

“…art by artists from previously colonized countries often refers to "invisible" cultures and acknowledges intersecting histories and streams of thought.”

“…when repressive government officials assert their will on the traditional values of citizens, the people often use folk art in protest to preserve their heritage (Zug, 1994).”

Classroom Applications
“1. To explore the implications of political art in schools, teachers need to help students investigate relevant and known historical and contemporary examples for reference and discussion.”

“Once students evaluate artworks that they can understand and appreciate, they should be encouraged to identify the political aspects of all art, including those that are more contemporary and of non-Western heritage.”

“2. For further discussion, art educators can find contemporary political art in many communities both here and abroad. Viewers often find that artists produce political art in countries where oppression, individual rights, and current events are of serious concern.”

“3. …teachers and students might look to their communities, homes, and local media to find further examples of art with political implications.”

“To see the political in art, teachers need to help students assess the objectives of artists and the effect of their art in the community.”

“4. Teachers can help students engage in the fabric of their communities through personal artistic responses (jagodzinski, 2001).”

“…through personal response to global concerns, students could explore many of the unresolved problems that we have previously encountered.”

“…art teachers could show students how they can have a voice in the community through art. To identify specific global or regional issues, teachers could help students analyze local newspaper headlines, editorial cartoons, and advertising imagery.”

“Through reflection, teachers could help students identify more personal and local topics of concern such as school or home violence, social isolation, oppressive policies, intolerance, limited student support, and stereotypical expectations.”

“This approach encourages students to look at environmental and social structures from multiple perspectives.”

Summary
“By analyzing art from a political point of view and encouraging students to think of the political aspects of their own work, art teachers can make both the presentation and production of art a more meaningful endeavor.”

Notes on Arnold, A. (2005). Confronting Violence through the Arts: A Thematic Approach. Art Education, 58 (4), 20-33

“An arts classroom gives children the time and place to confront images of war and violence and decode the multiple levels of meaning (Arnold, 1997) found within them.”

“The third, fourth, and fifth-grade students in my university preservice "after-school-art" class looked at several narrative works by Francisco Goya, Kathe Kollwitz, Frank Gaylord, II, and Pablo Picasso, and discussed the stories and imagery in each.”

“Each student interpreted the many themes found in the artworks within the context of their personal lives.”

“The experience was a time of discovery and a time to confront the multiple realities of their lives.”

“A desire to protect children from the harsh realities of life may cause teachers to avoid showing children art that has difficult imagery. Yet, a strong and powerful understanding of the human condition can be gleaned from the presentation of the array of subjects found in artworks-with an array of emotional expression (Broudy, 1972).”

Exploring Questions-Without-Answers through the Arts
“The teacher and students raised critical questions (Giroux, 1988) in rapid-fire succession. Every voice was heard, yet no set answers were given, only speculation and debate. The students gave one solution and then another as they became involved with the deeper meanings of each work.”

“The students’ discussion and explanations became a way for them to make sense of these large and complex paintings. Careful analysis of the detail and complexity in the paintings provoked ideas and many questions (Broudy, 1987).”

“This collaborative viewing process, where each answer was respected and considered, gave the children time to peel away the multiple themes related to war and reveal greater realities about war: the tragedy, sorrow, loss, and despair. For example, the students' collages revealed that a personal awareness of the aftermath of war was a reality for each child.”

Multimodal Arts Explorations
“After viewing and discussing reproductions of the works, the children experimented with heavy collage materials…”

“Each student moved back and forth between the expressive modalities of speech, drawing and pasting, gesture and movement, and writing with great fluency (Pahi, 2003).”

Re-creating the Guernica Theme with Personal Stories
“The children's art and writing shows a great degree of personal identification with the chaotic aftermath of war.”

Aesthetic Confrontations
“The children seemed to pull inspiration from many realms of their world-from the artwork as well as from their "everyday aesthetic" (Duncum, 1999).”

“There was a level of authenticity in the images that revealed that most of the young artists had placed themselves at the center of the blast, just as Picasso had in Guernica.”

“The art room can be a place of differences and debate as well as shared hopes for the future.”

“Discussing feelings about art can be both instructive and cathartic.”

Examining Beliefs
“Children are continually exposed to traumatic events through the media.”

“Images are too often presented in rapid-fire succession with very little time for processing or reflection. Children can become bewildered and depressed when asked to understand events that are developmentally beyond their years (Elkind, 2001).”

“In the art classroom on the other hand, children have time to confront important themes. The process of viewing, listening, discussing, and then creating, allows the child to place information in a context that makes it more understandable (Bruner, 1977).”

“The artistic process can create a safe place for children to address long-held beliefs and prejudices.”

“Discussion of art with serious themes can encourage a new analysis and understanding and move the theme to a more abstract and universal level.”

“The Prisoners, The Shootings of May Third 1808, the Korean War Memorial, and Guernica are quite different from each other and run through a range of expression, from betrayal and desolation to terror. These images…call for an examination of the essential nature of war: power, aggression, chaos, and loss. They call for a discussion of beliefs about the culturally popular myths that glorify war and create the dichotomies of good-guys/bad-guys, and hero/victim (Giroux, 2000).”

Multimodal Learning
“With time and practice, children become better at expressing themselves in myriad ways.”

“Those with fewer linguistic skills may prefer the medium of the dance, the play, the song, or the visual arts to give voice to their ideas (McGuire, 1984).”

“When several sensory and expressive modalities (visual, auditory, oral and kinesthetic) are combined in a lesson, the potential for perceptual understanding and expression is enhanced (Arnold, 1997).”

“Ideas become more specific and powerful when artmaking and writing are coupled.”

Conclusion
“Children need the opportunity to give expression to life events that are tragic or senseless to them. They need time and permission to reflect in meaningful ways on events over which they have no control. The artistic process can provide such an avenue.”

Notes on Milbrandt M. et al (2004)

Notes on: Milbrandt M. et Al (2004). Teaching to Learn: A Constructivist Approach to Shared Responsibility. Art Education, 57 (5), 19-33.

“Student decision-making has undoubtedly been the crux of creative and critical thinking and is central to a humanistic approach to art education (Lowenfeld & Brittain, 1970; Eisner, 1972; Gaitskell & E Hurwitz, 1975). Issues of choice and voice are also central to contemporary art education (Chalmers, 1992; Efland, Freedman, & Stuhr, 1996; Gaudelius & Speirs, 2003; Barakett & Sacca, 2003; Sullivan, 2003, Anderson & Milbrandt, 2004), and are, essential in the processes of analysis, interpretation, and the construction of meaning for students as they look at art (Anderson, 1995; Barrett, 2000).”

“King (1983) suggests that self-determination or choice is a powerful motivational force in learning that simultaneously enhances both achievement and attitudes about learning. Yet with the current emphasis on educational accountability, teachers sometimes find it increasingly difficult to step out of their roles as educational gatekeepers and allow students a greater sense of agency and voice in their own learning.”

Constructing Learning
“…constructivists view knowledge as constructed by the learner in a particular context, and not pre-existent or given from an expert or authority.”

“Yet in the daily lives of teachers in K-12 classrooms where a modernist paradigm typically prevails, a continual emphasis is placed on teacher accountability and on student acquisition of established knowledge.”

What is Constructivist Theory?
“…at the heart of the constructivist approach to education is the understanding that students are in control of their own learning.”

“Phillips (1995) identifies three distinct student roles in constructivism. These roles are described as the active learner, the social learner, and the creative learner.”

“The creation of meaningful artwork involves the student in a construction of identity through purposeful and expressive visual language (Anderson & Milbrandt, 2004).”

“Learning embedded in social interactions in which students discuss, debate, investigate, and explore multiple viewpoints rather than accept the teacher's viewpoint as the only authority offer other powerful avenues for active art learning and connect students to the real world beyond the classroom.”

“From a constructivist viewpoint, knowledge and understanding are created or recreated; it is not enough for the student to be only actively involved in producing artwork. Structuring purpose and meaning should be at the heart of artistic activity.”

“Both Dewey and Piaget suggest that motivation for the construction of knowledge often comes from an experience of cognitive conflict or puzzlement.”

“As creative learners, students often experience a synthesis of personal or established knowledge during problem solving that continually produces a change or shift in cognitive structures. Because knowledge is authentically acquired both in the classroom and beyond, students need to build structures of cognition that accommodate and assimilate fragmented knowledge into previously acquired understandings-a process Efland and others have termed flexible cognition (Efland, 2002).”

“Chandra and Basinger (2000) utilize art history constructivist inquiry methods to engage elementary students in the development of contextual understandings of African artworks.”

“Participation in an in-depth rigorous analysis of artifacts from multiple viewpoints involves students in a more integrated and richer view of the world that more closely simulates realworld problem solving than does traditional classroom instruction (Windschitl, 2000; Scherer, 1999).”

“Through critical discussions about art, students are challenged to consider crucial human questions regarding cultural images of what is true, beautiful, and moral (Scherer, 1999) and to construct or re-construct their own understandings and values.”

“The analysis, interpretation, and production of artworks engages students in many opportunities for decision-making as well as critical and creative thinking (Hamblen, 1984).”

“For many teachers, balancing the increased demands of accountability and high performance standards with student interests and needs for self-determination becomes a high priority (Anderson & Milbrandt, 2004).”

Sharing the Responsibility
“In the spring of 2003, three Atlanta area high school art teachers implemented constructivist lessons to see how students would accept responsibility for their own learning and peer-teaching situations.”

“Led by these teachers, students generated their own lesson objectives and evaluation criteria.”

“Because the students wrote their own objectives, during the duration of the project there was little question about the intended lesson outcomes.”

“Compared to her past printmaking experiences, Abghari observed that these students seemed to work faster during this unit and accomplished more work in fewer periods. The students were more involved and engaged with their learning and worked much more independently.”

“This interaction among students seemed to build greater sensitivity and understanding of each other, as well as greater regard for one another's artwork.”

“The ongoing art historical and art critical discussions created a more holistic learning experience that also facilitated ongoing critical dialogue throughout the production phase of the lesson.”

“Many brought unsolicited related Internet articles to the class discussion and made stylistic and conceptual connections to their artwork-in-progress.”

“One of the major criticisms of constructivist theory and practice is that when students structure their own learning the result is trivial rather than rigorous (Brooks & Grennon Brooks, 1999). Others critics suggest constructivist methods only work with older, very mature students.”

“The teachers agree that as the students became more personally invested and empowered through their work they demonstrated higher levels of critical thinking in their remarks and interactions.”

The Teacher's Role
“These teachers facilitated a framework with components similar to those suggested by Dever and Hobbs (2000) in which students actively engage, investigate, share, and assess their own performance.”

“Within each lesson, teachers prepared a baseline of introductory information, but encouraged students to determine where they wanted the learning to take them and the level of performance they would attain.”

“While constructivist lessons are typically more student-centered than traditional lessons, the role of the teacher-as-facilitator is critical to student success.”

Guidelines for Successful Constructivist Teaching
“Provide students with a variety of tools for research (i.e. Internet sites, digital cameras, books, and maps) so students become the primary research investigators.”

“Frame strategies for several large and small group collaborations to foster peer support and interaction.”

“Develop a flexible classroom climate that encourages student inquiry and discussion.”

“Present numerous opportunities throughout the lesson for students to make individual choices about their artwork.”

“Negotiate lesson objectives and evaluation criteria with students.”

“Encourage students to create real world and cross-disciplinary connections that extend beyond the classroom. Help students construct a vision for their future, a purpose for learning, cross-disciplinary connections, and personal meaning in their work.”

“Act as a participant-facilitator in the teaching-learning process, rather than as an authoritarian who dispenses knowledge.”

“Encourage students to take ownership of their learning, develop expertise, and share their knowledge with others.”

“Rather than planning a lesson in which the teacher directs a classroom of students in one general pre-determined direction, the constructivist approach facilitates the movement of student learning in multiple directions.”

“It is important for teachers to develop a supportive network among other teachers who share a common interest in constructivist teaching and learning.”

“The development of a stronger student voice in learning does not diminish the teacher's role, standards, or outcomes, but rather encourages students to construct their own views, explore their own interests, engage their own passions, and create newly empowered visions of self and learning in a supportive community.”

DBAE vs. TAB

 
DBAE (Discipline-Based Art Education) Verses TAB (Teaching for Artistic Behavior):
Two Approaches to Art Education


Joni H. Hough



University of North Carolina at Charlotte
ARTE 5121
Dr. David Gall
December 10, 2009




 Discipline-based art education (DBAE) has been the leading framework for art education for the past twenty-five years.  According to Day (as cited in Stankiewicz, 2000),
…the discipline-based approach has influenced the National Standards for Arts Education, the framework for the recent National Assessment of Educational Progress in the arts, the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards guidelines for art certification, as well as state art guidelines, district art programs, and the art teaching of many individuals (p. 311).
Teaching for Artistic Behavior (TAB) is a choice-based approach to art education (http://teachingforartisticbehavior.org/, 2009).  This paper will compare and contrast these two methods to art education.
           
In 1982, the J. Paul Getty Trust established the Getty Center for Education in the Arts (Duke, 1988).  According to Duke (1988), “Unlike a grant-making foundation, which funds the programs of others, the primary purpose of the Getty is to create and operate its own programs” (p. 7).   “By the mid 1980s, the Getty Center for Education in the Arts…became a major catalyst for reform in art education” (Delacruz & Dunn, 1995, p. 46).   Duke (1988) states,
The Center found that the status of art education had declined alarmingly.  Most students spend 12 years in school during which they receive some 12,000 hours of instruction in all subjects.  Less than one percent of this time is spent in studying any of the art forms, and 80 percent of all students who graduate from public high schools have little, if any, instruction in the arts at all... Moreover, arts instruction in many places has been limited to teaching technical skills for making art - not to teaching students about the historical and critical aspects of art as well. While studio-oriented art may have been a satisfying experience for a few innately gifted students, it meant that children were not receiving sufficient instruction in the cultural and historical contributions of art or in how to analyze, interpret, and value works of art (p. 7).
DBAE became the art program championed by the Getty Center for Education in the Arts.  DBAE had the full weight of the Getty Center for Education in the Arts behind it with programs for public advocacy, professional training, the creation of DBAE model programs, theoretical research, and curriculum (Duke, 1988).

Through DBAE, the Getty Center for Education in the Arts would change the face of art education.  According to Delacruz and Dunn (1995),
In 1987, in the special Summer issue of the Journal of Aesthetic Education devoted to aspects of DBAE, Gilbert Clark, Michael Day, and Dwaine Greer boldly spelled out the theory of DBAE. According to Clark, Day, and Greer (1987) discipline-based art education draws content from four foundational disciplines-art studio, art history, art criticism, and aesthetics-as these disciplines are defined by a community of scholars and experts who have devoted themselves to inquiry in these fields of study. Formal written curricula in the visual arts should be developed for all grade levels within the school district. Curricula should be structured sequentially and hierarchically, and implemented on a district-wide basis. Student achievement and program effectiveness should be formally and systematically assessed and evaluated (p. 47).
DBAE elevated art education to a new status.  It was now an actual discipline, with a testable curriculum.  Hamblen (1987) maintains that, “The language of DBAE is one of a no-frills, no-nonsense program that leaves little doubt that budgeted money will be well-spent and that there will be no hedging on what needs to be done and what will be accomplished” (p. 69).
           
During the late 1980s and the early 1990s, DBAE flourished, but it was not without its critics.  Hamblen (1987) states,
 In my opinion these educational perspectives alone are not adequate to the needs of a pluralistic society undergoing rapid change and requiring a variety of types of input and a variety of view-points. These rationalistic perspectives do not allow for curriculum choices being problematic and open to dispute and challenge (p. 69).
Hamblen (1987) further condemns the art criticism aspect of DBAE, maintaining,
Considering, however, that children will be studying exemplars, this aspect of art criticism is also predetermined in that children will be asked to evaluate what has already been given validation by the learned. Focusing on what is deemed to represent the aesthetic heights of a culture could give students a distorted view of art and a view that has little resemblance to the world in which they live (p. 72).
Hamblen (1987) also points out,
If standardized testing becomes an overriding concern, lower cognitive levels can be expected to constitute much of the art curriculum. The metaphoric qualities of art, so integral to its understanding, will have little place in the identification and convergent responses required by objective test questions. Statements that art instruction should emulate other subject areas need to be assessed as to whether the dominant characteristics of general education, beyond their legitimating power, are desirable. It is in the area of the cognitive level of instruction occurring that the consequences of teacher-proof materials, predefined outcomes, and standardized testing could become all too evident (p. 75).
According to Stankiewicz (2000), “Although DBAE initially signaled attention to content, and was criticized for the other two components of art education – the learner and the social context” (p. 311).
           
The Getty Center for Education in the Arts did listen to some of DBAE’s critics.  “In their attempt to accommodate diverse views about art education (and the vehement criticisms of DBAE in particular), the GCEA (Getty Center for Education in the Arts) found itself in the midst of the multicultural education movement” (Delacruz & Dunn, 1995, p. 47).  Delacruz and Dunn also state,
Many of the participants attending the 1989 and 1992 Issues Seminars identified common aims for multicultural education and DBAE. Both movements recognized the need for programs of study that embrace ethnic diversity. Both movements recognized the need to identify, examine, and incorporate alternative ways of looking at art.  Both movements recognize the need to address the problem of context: that is, the attempt to study artists, art forms, and cultures out of their original settings. And finally, both movements recognize that no single voice in the field ‘speaks for’ DBAE or multiculturalism (p. 48).

Although, the Getty Center for Education in the Arts did address the need for multicultural content to be added to the DBAE curriculum, there are still issues with some of the basic tenets of DBAE.  For example, Stankiewicz (2000) points out,
Passive metaphors of learners receiving objectified knowledge from external authorities should be replaced by conceptions of the learner as an active agent, setting personal goals for learning, and creating meaning through encounters with art (Erickson, Katter, Lankford, Roucher, & Stewart, 1999). Both content and learner are structured by gender, ethnicity, class, and all the other cultural factors that contribute to the production and reproduction of shared values (p. 311).
It is in this area that TAB excels.
           
Whereas DBAE had financial and political support from the Getty Center for Education in the Arts, TAB is a grassroots organization that was formed for and by art teachers (Douglas & Jaquith, 2009).  Although TAB is supported by Brown University, Massachusetts College of Art and Design, and Bridgewater State College, “…it remains an independent movement firmly planted in classroom practice” (Douglas & Jaquith, 2009, p. xii).  According to teachingforartisticbehavior.org (2009),
The concept emerged over 30 years ago in Massachusetts classrooms through the need for more authentic art making experiences. United through Massachusetts College of Art (MassArt), teachers working in isolation discovered others who also held belief in the child as the artist. With the support of MassArt, NAEA and The Education Alliance at Brown University, the Teaching for Artistic Behavior Partnership (TAB) was formed in 2001 and incorporated in 2007 (http://teachingforartisticbehavior.org/).
           
According to Douglas (2007), students in a TAB classroom can work at their own pace, work from their strengths, follow a train of thought over time, learn from and work with peers, be “on task” for a greater portion of class time, develop a working style, explore their interests in visual form, form cooperative groups and engage in positive social interaction, and take responsibility for the care of materials and the classroom.  Teachers in a TAB classroom can observe students working to determine strengths and weaknesses, work with small groups of interested students while others work independently, allowing for more in-depth instruction, offer special “scaffolding” to struggling students, get to know students through their personal styles, expect students to come to class highly motivated and ready to work (Douglas, 2007).

There are four practices that form the structure of choice-based art education.  First, the student is the artist.  Douglas and Jaquith (2009) maintain, “This powerful statement insures that students will have control over their subject matter, materials, and approach” (p. 9).  The teacher presents a five minute demonstration of a new material, technique, or art concept at the beginning of each class, ensuring that content standards are met.  After that, students choose at which studio center they will work.
The second practice is pedagogy.  Douglas and Jaquith (2009) state,
Choice-based teaching comes in many forms: direct and indirect (through visuals and references), whole-group demonstrations and discussions, small groups with students who choose a particular exploration, and one-to-one interactions.  These multiple approaches are possible because student independence is encouraged.  Teacher roles include demonstrating, modeling, facilitating, caching, providing curriculum content, and altering that content as a result of observations made in class.  The teacher also ensures accessibility of art materials, tools, and visual references for independent learning through student-directed experiences (p. 10-11).
Because so many teaching styles are utilized, teachers are more likely to meet the needs of every student in a diverse student population. 

The third practice in choice-based art education is classroom context.  Douglas and Jaquith (2009) assert,
The ideal learning environment for student-driven artmaking requires the efficient structure of time, careful arrangement of space, and thoughtful choice of materials.  Good classroom management allows teachers to respond in a timely manner to student needs.  Predictability of studio centers is central to the effectiveness of choice-based teaching and learning, and enables students to plan ahead for their art class (p. 13).

The final practice in choice-based art education is assessment.  According to the website, teachingforartisticbehavior.org,
Assessment is ongoing and students are coached and encouraged to self-assess as they work. When students are working independently, the choice teacher is able to make general and one-on-one observations of what students know and can do. Future demonstrations and assistance are directly tied to these observations. Assessment is tailored to the specific district expectations. (http://teachingforartisticbehavior.org/faqs.html, 2009).
Student-directed exhibitions are also used as a form of assessment and as a tool for learning.  Douglas and Jaquith (2009) maintain,
Students select artwork to exhibit, and their choices reflect self-evaluation of their recent work.  Empowering students to organize and direct art shows extends their knowledge to the fields of aesthetics and criticism.  As they determine which pieces to exhibit and how to arrange the exhibition, students develop skills necessary for growth in the visual arts (p. 15).

According to Greene (as cited in Burton, 2000),
Young people are too often bored in schools because we do not offer them meaningful challenges, we do not invite them to bring their own experiences in to the arena of learning, we do not ask of them the kind of reflection and exploration of possibilities that engages their thinking, and we do not offer them insights and skills in those non-verbal languages of the arts where imagination can open up new corners of reality (p. 330).
This may be the case in DBEA classrooms, but with TAB, this is not the case.  Andrews (2005) states, “Students are engaged in artmaking, art planning, and art reflection. They are the instigators of their art curriculum; not passive bodies waiting for instruction” (p.39).  Andrews (2005) further states, “This arrangement fosters greater interaction among the student artists, brings more ideas into the art room, and creates an atmosphere of enthusiasm and creativity” (p. 39)
           
DBAE has impacted art education in the United States for the last twenty-five years.  It has brought legitimacy to K-12 art education.  The art education community has improved upon DBAE over the years; however, it is still not a perfect approach to art education.  DBAE focuses too much on content and not enough on the actual students.  TAB on the other hand, is a student-centered, choice-based approach to art education.  In the TAB classroom, a variety of teaching methods are used, increasing the likelihood of reaching all students.   With TAB, students do not just learn about art, they are artists.


References
Andrews, B. H.  (2005, July).  Art, reflection, and creativity in the classroom: A student-driven
art course.  [Electronic version].  Art Education, 58(4), 35-40.
Burton, J. M.  (2000, Summer).  The configuration of meaning: Learner-centered art education
revisited.  [Electronic version].  Studies in Art Education, 41(4), 330-345.
Delacruz, E. M., & Dunn, P. C.  (1995, November).  DBAE: The next generation.  [Electronic
version].  Art Education, 48(6), 46-53.
Douglas, K.  (2007, December).  Starting with the students: Choice-based art education.  Art
Beat.  Retrieved November 1, 2009 from
http://teachingforartisticbehavior.org/articles.html
Douglas, K. M., & Jaquith, D. B.  (2009).  Engaging learners through artmaking: Choice-based
art education in the classroom.  New York: Teachers College Press.
Duke, L. L.  (1988, March).  The getty center for education in the arts and discipline-based art
education.  [Electronic version].  Art Education, 41(2), 7-12.
Hamblen, K. A. (1987, Winter).  An examination of discipline-based art education issues.
[Electronic version].  Art Education, 28(2), 68-78.
Stankiewicz, M. A.  (2000, Summer).  Discipline and the future of art education.  [Electronic
version].  Studies in Art Education, 41(4), 301-313.